In accordance with the newest “VAT hole” report printed by the European Fee, value-added tax (VAT) compliance decreased in 2023. The VAT compliance hole—the extra VAT income that could possibly be collected if all taxpayers, shoppers, and companies totally complied with VAT guidelines—elevated from 7.9 p.c in 2022 (€101 billion) to 9.5 p.c in 2023 (€128 billion).
In 2023, the most important compliance gaps have been noticed in Romania (30 p.c), Malta (24.2 p.c), Poland (16 p.c), Lithuania (15.1 p.c), and Italy (15 p.c). The smallest compliance gaps have been registered in Austria (1 p.c), Finland (3 p.c), Cyprus (3.3 p.c), and Portugal (3.6 p.c). Nevertheless, in absolute phrases, 75 p.c of the VAT hole comes from simply six international locations: France, Germany, Italy, Poland, Romania, and Spain.
This 12 months’s report additionally contains chosen European Union (EU) candidate and potential candidate international locations. In 2023, VAT compliance gaps ranged from 24.6 p.c in Albania to eight.1 p.c in Kosovo and 5.4 p.c in Georgia.
EU VAT Compliance Gaps Elevated in 2023
The VAT compliance hole elevated in 17 EU international locations and decreased in 9 international locations. To know this common improve within the compliance hole, a extra thorough evaluation of the VAT compliance hole is required.
What Causes the VAT Compliance Hole?
The VAT compliance hole is triggered not solely by VAT avoidance or gaps in enforcement but in addition by unpaid VAT because of bankruptcies, insolvencies, or authorized taxA tax is a compulsory fee or cost collected by native, state, and nationwide governments from people or companies to cowl the prices of basic authorities providers, items, and actions. optimization.
Utilizing Eurostat data on bankruptcies, we discover a constructive however low correlation of 0.19 between the rise within the variety of bankruptcies and the lower in compliance. In different phrases, when bankruptcies rise, compliance tends to dip, as VAT owed turns into uncollectable. However, in the Netherlands, the place VAT compliance elevated, a stark improve in bankruptcies was additionally noticed. Subsequently, the VAT compliance hole could be revised upward within the 2026 launch of the “VAT hole” report. In accordance with the Fee’s report, the general lower in compliance was because of VAT income rising at a slower tempo than the estimated complete legal responsibility.
Within the 2025 “VAT hole” report, the VAT compliance hole for the years 2021 and 2022 was additionally revised upward, by a median of 0.6 and 0.9 share factors, respectively. Nevertheless, the 2021 knowledge was additionally revised upward in final 12 months’s report (2024) by one other 1 share level. Because the report notes, this was “because of the extraordinary measures launched (and revoked) in these years” and to the “inconsistent therapy of deferrals, and the decrease high quality of nationwide statistics.” As we highlighted in previous years’ posts, in lots of international locations, 2020 VAT funds have been pushed into the 2021 fiscal 12 months. This postponement artificially elevated VAT tax assortment in 2021, whereas having no influence on the VAT tax legal responsibility, explaining the bogus improve in VAT compliance in 2021. Whereas the VAT compliance hole for the 12 months 2021 was revised upward by 1.6 share factors on common, for international locations like Croatia, Czechia, Germany, Italy, Latvia, and the Netherlands, the VAT compliance hole was revised upward by greater than 4 share factors.
The VAT compliance hole will doubtless proceed to extend barely within the coming years. The report estimates for 2024 present that the VAT compliance hole in absolute phrases is anticipated to extend in 12 (8, in relative phrases) of the 22 international locations for which estimates have been out there. Moreover, 2024 chapter knowledge already printed by Eurostat portrays a somber perspective on companies working within the EU, as bankruptcies continued to extend in 20 EU international locations between 2023 and 2024. The most important will increase in bankruptcies have been noticed within the Netherlands (30.3 p.c), Sweden (30 p.c), Spain (25.5 p.c), and Germany (22.9 p.c).
The European Fee is prioritizing efforts to cut back the VAT compliance hole by intensifying actions towards fraud and avoidance. Nevertheless, current research signifies that present VAT fraud estimates are methodologically flawed and persistently overstated. Subsequently, earlier than introducing new VAT policies, a extra sturdy evaluation of the potential influence of those measures is required.
What Is the VAT Actionable Coverage Hole?
Whereas the European Fee focuses on bettering VAT compliance, coverage is a serious contributor to VAT income losses. The VAT actionable coverage hole—the extra VAT income that might realistically be collected by eliminating lowered charges and sure exemptions—is 27.1 p.c (in 2024, the newest out there knowledge). In absolute phrases, the VAT actionable coverage hole amounted to €773.5 billion in 2024 and €743.2 billion in 2023, six occasions the compliance hole.
The VAT coverage hole is made up of two elements: the price hole and the exemption hole. The previous represents misplaced VAT income because of lowered VAT charges, whereas the latter represents misplaced VAT income because of sure items and providers being exempt from the VAT. Policymakers usually justify exemptions and lowered charges with arguments that they promote the consumption of sure items and providers to handle fairness, environmental, and different coverage targets. However exemptions and lowered charges are dangerous coverage as a result of they distort consumption, inefficiently ship fiscal advantages, add complexity for companies, and scale back income, forcing governments to depend on much less economically environment friendly income sources.
Nevertheless, there are some providers—particularly, imputed rents, the supply of publicly offered items, and monetary providers—which might be VAT-exempt as a result of it could be troublesome to levy VAT on them. Subtracting the quantity of misplaced VAT income brought on by these providers from the final coverage hole leaves us with the actionable coverage hole (i.e., the actionable exemption hole plus the speed hole), which is the quantity of extra VAT income lawmakers might realistically elevate by eliminating lowered charges and sure exemptions.
In 2024, the typical actionable coverage hole for the EU was 27.1 p.c—of which 12 p.c was because of lowered charges (price hole) and 15 p.c to the actionable portion of the exemption hole.
The price hole is smaller in international locations that depend on lowered charges much less, comparable to Denmark (0.7 p.c), Estonia (2.4 p.c), Latvia (3.6 p.c), Bulgaria (4.1 p.c), and Lithuania (4.6 p.c). Nevertheless, the speed gaps in Eire (21.4 p.c), Greece (18.5 p.c), Austria (17.7 p.c), Italy (16.8 p.c), Portugal (16.2 p.c), Spain (15.9 p.c), Poland (15.5 p.c), and Croatia (15.1 p.c) present vital forgone income due to lowered charges. The best actionable exemption gaps are noticed in Spain (21.7 p.c), Estonia (19.5 p.c), Poland (18.3 p.c), Greece (17.8 p.c), Slovenia (16 p.c), Germany (15.7 p.c), Italy (15.2 p.c), and France (15 p.c).
Moreover, this 12 months’s report distinguishes between the nationwide policy-driven VAT exemption hole and the EU policy-mandated VAT exemption hole, exemptions required by the VAT directive. On one hand, the best EU policy-mandated exemption gaps have been noticed in Portugal (5.6 p.c) and Belgium (5 p.c), whereas the smallest gaps have been noticed in Bulgaria (1.2 p.c), Estonia (1.6 p.c), and Croatia (1.8 p.c). These gaps have been primarily pushed by the exemptions utilized to personal medical health insurance, non-public training, and insurance-related actions.
Alternatively, the best nationwide policy-driven exemption gaps have been noticed in Spain (18.6 p.c), Estonia (17.9 p.c), and Poland (16.1 p.c). The nationwide policy-driven exemption hole was smaller in Bulgaria (4.9 p.c), Cyprus (4.9 p.c), Austria (5 p.c), and Croatia (5.9 p.c).
Total, the best actionable coverage gaps have been noticed in Spain (37.6 p.c), Greece (36.3 p.c), Eire (34.7 p.c), Poland (33.7 p.c), Italy (32 p.c), Portugal (29.8 p.c), Slovenia (27.9 p.c), Belgium (27.6 p.c), and France (27.1 p.c). Spain’s actionable coverage hole was due partly to the applying of various oblique taxes within the Canary Islands, Ceuta, and Melilla. The actionable coverage hole was smaller in Bulgaria (10.2 p.c), Denmark (11.4 p.c), Latvia (14.8 p.c), and Lithuania (15.5 p.c).
In accordance with the information within the newest “VAT hole” report, between 2022 and 2024, the VAT actionable coverage hole elevated from 26.1 p.c to 27.1 p.c. The typical actionable coverage hole for the EU elevated by 1 share level, of which 0.2 share factors have been because of the improve within the price hole and 0.8 share factors have been because of the improve within the actionable exemption hole.
Nevertheless, within the earlier “VAT hole” report (2024), for the 12 months 2022, the VAT actionable coverage hole was 19 p.c, 7 share factors under the determine proven on this 12 months’s report for a similar indicator. This alteration is because of a big change within the actionable exemption hole knowledge. The 2024 report estimated the EU’s actionable exemption hole for 2022 at 7 p.c, whereas the 2025 report raises this determine to 14.15 p.c. Whereas the typical estimate of the actionable exemption hole elevated by 7.2 share factors, country-level revisions ranged from 1.2 share factors in Cyprus to 10.2 share factors in Belgium. Whereas the report notes that monetary and insurance coverage providers are actually handled as actionable exemptions, these two sectors solely account for as much as 2.7 share factors of the 7.2 share level distinction.
However, each financial and insurance coverage providers are topic to completely different types of taxation throughout EU Member States, past the VAT framework. In France, the insurance premium tax relevant to motor third‑celebration legal responsibility insurance coverage reaches as much as 33 p.c.
The upward pattern of the VAT actionable coverage hole will doubtless change in 2025, as the short-term price reductions to VAT on power and meals merchandise, as a worth assist measure to cushion the influence of a pointy rise in power costs and inflation, expired. Nevertheless, some international locations continued to introduce lowered charges on quite a lot of items and providers to extend fairness or to stimulate sure sectors of the economic system. If no new necessary price reductions are launched, the VAT base will broaden, lowering the VAT price hole and consequently the actionable coverage hole in 2025.
Because the compliance hole is anticipated to extend barely within the following years, policymakers might want to intently monitor each compliance and price gaps. In a survey concerning firms’ boundaries to conducting enterprise within the EU single market, VAT ranked first, at 17 p.c. Subsequently, policymakers ought to spend money on reforming VAT techniques to shut each compliance and coverage gaps in ways in which enhance the general effectivity of their tax techniques.
Keep knowledgeable on the tax insurance policies impacting you.
Subscribe to get insights from our trusted specialists delivered straight to your inbox.
Subscribe
Share this text